FEBRUARY 10 ST. SCHOLASTICA, virgin
Those of us who remember with fondness the Broadway musical (made into a movie), FIDDLER ON THE ROOF, can remember the song, TRADITIONNNNNN! Jesus' exasperation with the strictly observant scribes and Pharisees is clear in all four gospels. The encounter in today's gospel can be supplemented in great detail by reading Matthew 23! That chapter is entirely devoted to a denunciation of the misuse of "tradition" to maintain a position of power or a bad "status quo." It is a problem that is still with us today in our church.
A useful distinction can be helpful. Tradition (with a capital "T") in the church refers to the teaching of the early church Fathers/Mothers who either knew the apostles or at least the earliest associates of the apostles and passed this teaching on through their own disciples such as St. Augustine, St. Basil, St. Gregory, St. John Damascene, etc.. This is enshrined in such things as the Nicene Creed. "Tradition" - small "t" - refers to practices or customs that have gained such popularity that they almost assume the status of "law." These are always subject to change or development. Postures and gestures and clothing and devotions, etc. are meant to assist but not to rule. A certain level of uniformity is necessary to promote unity, but Jesus' warnings about this should always be kept in mind. Any pastor can relate the challenges that cultural diversity can present at events like a wedding or funeral!!!!
Changes that have occurred in the wake of the Second Vatican Council have highlighted the tension between, and the necessity of, the distinction between Tradition and traditions. Patience and careful study can offer a way forward in promoting sound and healthy expression of our faith. AMEN